PDA

View Full Version : The greatest version of FCOL......

Wario
17 Sep 2009, 23:09
VSyVziz2kIY

RJ agrees with me on this. Years ago we had a long conversation of MSN messenger about the awesomeness of this recording.
Evil One
18 Sep 2009, 01:33
The second greatest version. The best would be the original studio version.
daveake
18 Sep 2009, 08:51
Absolutely right.
RadioMaster
18 Sep 2009, 14:11
[YT]
RJ agrees with me on this. Years ago we had a long conversation of MSN messenger about the awesomeness of this recording.

must be getting old, cant for the life of me remember that lol
But I do agree with Chris here
Wario
18 Sep 2009, 14:55
must be getting old, cant for the life of me remember that lol
But I do agree with Chris here

you dont? Awwww... it had to be waayyaayayayayayayaay back in 2007, was like days after i first joined lol. I vaugly remember it. i just remember you saying you were particularly fond of the FCOL version that was sung for Rory's wife. Then i said "Oh, you mean el mocambo!" (not in those words but yea). I forget most of it too...
Evil One
18 Sep 2009, 15:18
The El Mocambo concert is probably the best example of Meat's early years.
Wario
18 Sep 2009, 16:29
The El Mocambo concert is probably the best example of Meat's early years.

yep that or the bottom line.
Evil One
18 Sep 2009, 16:37
I don't think Meat had got into his stride yet during the Bottom Line shows. El Mocambo is much better.
RadioMaster
18 Sep 2009, 16:51
i pretty much agree with that. Bottom Line always has this kinda improvised feel to me...if you get what I mean
Wario
18 Sep 2009, 18:32
I guess I can agree that he hit his stride post bottom line, father's place (pre bottom line) he really screws up all revved up.

I also hate how at the bottom line when it sounds as if Meat is introducing Hot patootie and hes gonna perform it, he goes into 2 outta three.

But Its really hard picking, as they both have pros and (very few) cons.

Either way, they both omit Johnny b. goode. don't know if a "1977 voice" meat version exists :|
glockenspiel
18 Sep 2009, 18:36
This early live FCOL is just a bit too 'raw' for me, to be the best ... audio-live, I prefer the 'Live Around The World' take; visually, there is something particularly stirring about the 'Live In Melbourne' take.
Evil One
18 Sep 2009, 18:37
There are a couple of recordings of All Revved Up where Meat comes in early. I think he does it on the 'Hot As Hell' show too. Which also features Johnny B. Goode!
Evil One
18 Sep 2009, 18:38
audio-live, I prefer the 'Live Around The World' take;
I think this one is too slow. Sped up slightly it would have been rather good.
Wario
18 Sep 2009, 18:41
There are a couple of recordings of All Revved Up where Meat comes in early. I think he does it on the 'Hot As Hell' show too. Which also features Johnny B. Goode!

Yea but thats not the 1977 voice, thats the late 1978 voice

And that version of all revved up doesn't mess up. You own Hot as hell, the edited hammersmith concert.

That version that only does the familiar riff once not twice. They edited out the second riff and segued meat right in. impressive edit.
RadioMaster
18 Sep 2009, 18:49
This early live FCOL is just a bit too 'raw' for me, to be the best ... audio-live, I prefer the 'Live Around The World' take; visually, there is something particularly stirring about the 'Live In Melbourne' take.

I dont know why, but those versions never did it for me. First off they both sound about the same to me, and halfway through I get bored most of the time.
THIS version though, for me even surpasses the album version. To me it's all what the early Meat Loaf was about.
WhenItComes2LovingU
20 Sep 2009, 22:06
The band sounds more real to me, for some reason, than any other version. I highly enjoy this clip.
nikox1
20 Sep 2009, 23:08
This early live FCOL is just a bit too 'raw' for me, to be the best ... audio-live, I prefer the 'Live Around The World' take; visually, there is something particularly stirring about the 'Live In Melbourne' take.

thats my favourite!! because he gives it everything hes got
he knew it was a big gamble doing it after so many years [ its melbourne for me ]
Wario
21 Sep 2009, 03:03
for me it goes

EM > MSO > Studio > LATW

Yes MSO is terrific, but when you actually have Jim on piano, can the entire Melbourne Symphony Orchestra compare?
Evil One
21 Sep 2009, 03:50
Perhaps you should do a poll on the subject?!

Bat1 > El Mocambo > MSO > LATW > Bottom Line Late Show > Bottom Line Early Show > Old Waldorf

It's a shame there isn't a decent quality version from the Cleveland Music Hall show.
RadioMaster
21 Sep 2009, 10:51
is that where that CBS convention thing was held?
Evil One
21 Sep 2009, 12:17
No idea. It's the one where you can clearly hear Jim pounding the piano all the way through.
RadioMaster
21 Sep 2009, 17:06
not sure if I heard that one