View Full Version : Songs that sound better in the studio?
Evil One
20 Oct 2010, 11:52
What songs do people thing sound better on the album? No matter how hard Meat may try, when singing it live he can't better the studio version. Note that I'm not knocking Meat's effort, just that the originals are better. :twisted:
For Crying Out Loud
Objects
Anything For Love
Everything Louder
Rock And Roll Dreams
Blnd As A Bat
Nowhere Fast
Bad Attitude
Did I Say That
Testify
robgomm
20 Oct 2010, 14:14
With respect I don't agree with most of those. Most of those sound better live imo simply because he conveys the emotion of the song better live.
Evil One
20 Oct 2010, 14:17
So what do you think is better?
Cherry.Loaf
20 Oct 2010, 15:56
Personally I prefer I'd do anything for love live. The Monsters loose works better in the studio to in my opinion
It's not really possible to do FCOL better live, because it's one of hardest songs to sing anyway. I thought some of his versions of AFL and RNR Dreams were done very well live.
Everything Louder Then Everything Else
The Monster Is Loose
Living on the Outside
Los Angeloser
Did I Say That?
Peace On Earth
Break It
Its All Coming Back To Me Now
In The Land Of The Pig
Do It!
Evil One
20 Oct 2010, 17:54
I thought some of his versions of AFL and RNR Dreams were done very well live.
Indeed they were, I just don't think Meat's managed to top the awesomeness of the studio versions (yet :twisted:)
robgomm
20 Oct 2010, 21:27
What songs do people thing sound better on the album? No matter how hard Meat may try, when singing it live he can't better the studio version. Note that I'm not knocking Meat's effort, just that the originals are better. :twisted:
For Crying Out Loud
Objects
Anything For Love
Everything Louder
Rock And Roll Dreams
Blnd As A Bat
Nowhere Fast
Bad Attitude
Did I Say That
Testify
Okay, FCOL was amazing live with the melbourne symphony orchestra, such an emotional powerful performance.
Objects there's such an amazing live version of that on live around the world, again it's the emotion that makes it.
Anything for love, well take your pick really, there's been some amazing performances of this song, couldn't pick one in particular but again better live for me.
Rock and roll dreams, same as above really, some incredible performances of that, and he still does it great now! Much better live imo.
Blind as a bat was great in concert all through the 3 bats tour, better live for me.
Nowhere fast, was great at Bottom Line 1985.
The last 3 I haven't really heard live so i'll have to agree.
But generally I always prefer his live performances to the studio recording simply because he can convery so much more emotion and story with his on stage performances. Anyway it's only my opinion which means **** lol
olblueeyes
20 Oct 2010, 21:28
So what do you think is better?
While it might not be as vocally perfect, I prefer Blind As A Bat on the Casa Live CD better than the album version. Meat's voice sounds great on it and the arrangement is much better than the studio version - it's got that piano thunder sadly missing from Bat 3's songs. The album version also has far too many audible splices where Meat's voice has been cut and pasted so he's not singing the whole line in one go.
AFL was also done better live at the Brits in 1994 IMO but it's close.
I always thought that AFL was far better on the album until I saw Meat perform it live on the CHSIB Tour a few years ago and he blew me away with the emotion he packed into it.
I think what I prefer on the album version is the higher pitch that Meat comes in at. On the live renditions over the past few years Meat has really bellowed the opening line (which I think he's said he does partly because he wants to pack more emotion into the start of the song). The live versions also tend to cut out the "when I watch you dance and the thunder rolls" verse which is my favourite part of the album song (which I understand is for timing purposes). In terms of reciorded live versions I think the LATW recording most closely resembles the album version.
Pretty much every song from Bat 1 I actually prefer live, especially since I found out Meat's voice was sped up!!!
Evil One
21 Oct 2010, 00:58
Pretty much every song from Bat 1 I actually prefer live
With the exception of FCOL, I agree.
The start of the album version of FCOL always makes the hair on the back of my neck stand up....its perfection.
What I like about the Melbourne show is the emotion Meat puts into the song though. There's something quite epic about Meat sat there obviously quite nervous and reading the lyrics from the pages on the ground- yet still delivering THAT performance. He could have blown it off and included a 'sound check' version for the Live CD, but the guy sat there heroically infront of a huge audience and delivered.
Pretty much every song from Bat 1 I actually prefer live, especially since I found out Meat's voice was sped up!!!
I was going to say the same thing, since like Meat said everything was sped up on Bat 1, every song on that sounds better live. I have to say, every song I have heard live from any album sounds better live. That is not to take away from the recorded version, but the emotion and passion Meat puts into his live performances make the songs come alive for me.
Carole
It's not really possible to do FCOL better live, because it's one of hardest songs to sing anyway. I thought some of his versions of AFL and RNR Dreams were done very well live.
I really have to totally disagree with that. I love Meat's performance of that on the MSO DVD, it is so powerful and takes my breath away every time I hear it.
Carole
I love the album versions because I have them and can listen to them any time I want. But like others I'll take the live version always over any album version because of the extra passion Meat packs into a performance. Blind As A Bat was stunning at the RAH. Objects live has on occasion moved me to tears. Did I Say That was wonderful the night I heard him sing it live, and he has delivered some spectacular AFLs in so many shows. Rock and Roll Dreams was superb in the US this year, and I loved seeing the songs from HCTB performed live, particularly Los Angeloser.
As for FCOL, he sat on a stool and sung it right the way through at the Storytellers concert I attended and it was simply the best, most passionate and electric performance I have ever heard from Meat. At the end as the final note died away you could have heard a pin drop .. and then a massive roar of applause as the audience jumped to its feet. Must have been very close to what happened at the CBS conference so may years ago .. except we had no tables to stand on :-) Magnificent.
Caryl
I wish I could have been there for that Caryl, from what you and others who were there have said, it was a magnificent performance. I agree about the albums, I love the recorded versions, but nothing beats a live performance. And I must admit there are a few faves from some of them, that I would love to hear a live version of. I know Meat has said he will never do Alive in concert, but I think it would be stunning if he did. It is such a moving song, it would be amazing to hear it in concert. I see another poll being done about this. Songs we'd like to hear live that haven't ever been done.
Carole
Smithie
21 Oct 2010, 17:18
I thought some of his versions of AFL and RNR Dreams were done very well live.
On the HCTB tour, I think it's the best versions of AFL and RNR Dreams I've ever heard. Although on AFL, the backing vocals are not as good without Kasim. The duet part is flawless though. I saw a Youtube clip of IICHY at soundcheck. Unfortunately, it was quickly removed. That song sounds MUCH better live.
On the HCTB tour, I think it's the best versions of AFL and RNR Dreams I've ever heard. Although on AFL, the backing vocals are not as good without Kasim. The duet part is flawless though. I saw a Youtube clip of IICHY at soundcheck. Unfortunately, it was quickly removed. That song sounds MUCH better live.
i hope you saved that? :shock:
Smithie
21 Oct 2010, 17:24
i hope you saved that? :shock:
Unfortunately, I don't have a clue how to save videos from Youtube. The picture wasn't the best quality but the sound was great. I saw it once and the next time the user had removed it.
Unfortunately, I don't have a clue how to save videos from Youtube. The picture wasn't the best quality but the sound was great. I saw it once and the next time the user had removed it.
:(
was meat singing or was it just patti for SC? when i tried to hear IICHY at PNC, all i heard was patti
White of High
29 Oct 2010, 11:32
1. For Crying Out Loud
2. A Kiss Is A Terrible Thing To Waste
3. Anything For Love
4. Rock And Roll Dreams
And mostly all of the songs since the CHSIB era...
Smithie
04 Nov 2010, 17:14
:(
was meat singing or was it just patti for SC? when i tried to hear IICHY at PNC, all i heard was patti
It was just Patti, WarioLoaf. Hopefully they will add IICHY to future shows because it sounds like we are missing out on an awesome live performance.
The Monster Is Loose AND It's All Coming Back ;)
unbekannt
04 Nov 2010, 18:30
Does anybody here have that IICHY clip? :shock: I would so love to see it!
duke knooby
04 Nov 2010, 18:35
whats IICHY?
allrevvedup
04 Nov 2010, 18:57
If I can't have you
duke knooby
04 Nov 2010, 19:03
If I can't have you
i dont want nobody baby :twisted:
danke
A Slice Of English
04 Nov 2010, 19:30
The Monster Is Loose AND It's All Coming Back ;)
I actually like the live version of Its All Coming Back To Me Now from the live version released in 2007 (NOT the 3 Bats version) and prefer it to the studio version.
Evil One
04 Nov 2010, 20:04
Which live version would that be then? I only know of two: The 3 Bats DVD/CD which is ok and the Ken Bruce radio show which was appalling.
A Slice Of English
04 Nov 2010, 20:37
It's on the UK iTunes for 59p. Regrettably it doesn't say where it was recorded.
Evil One
04 Nov 2010, 20:45
Grrr. I don't do iTunes! Are you 100% sure it's not from the 3 Bats Live show?
The only live one I can find on iTunes is from the 3 Bats Live concert.
snider22
04 Nov 2010, 21:24
When I searched for the song on the iTunes UK the one that slice is referring to is #18 on the list. Sounds like live with some studio vocals snuck in. Definitely better than the 3 Bats version, Good find Slice.
A Slice Of English
05 Nov 2010, 01:53
When I searched for the song on the iTunes UK the one that slice is referring to is #18 on the list. Sounds like live with some studio vocals snuck in. Definitely better than the 3 Bats version, Good find Slice.
Ah thank you...
And Evil, yes it is definitely different to the 3 Bats version. For starters it's 5.59 long, not 5.51...!
vBulletin® v3.8.10, Copyright ©2000-2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.