HOF discussion - R&R Heaven

[The Flying Mouse]

:twisted: Here's your chance to have your say on why you think your favourites should be enducted to our hall of fame, or even why you think other nominees don't make the grade.

As always, please respect the opinions of others, even if you don't agree with them.

Your nominees are................

James Brown
Johnny Cash (2)
Ray Charles
Clarence Clemons (2)
Sam Cooke
Sammy Davis Jnr
Ronnie James Dio
Danny Federici
George Harrison
Jeff Healey
Jimi Hendrix (2)
Buddy Holly
Michael Jackson
Janis Joplin
John Lennon (2)
Freddy Mercury (2)
Jim Morrison
Roy Orbison (3)
Elvis Presley
Bon Scott
Joe Strummer
Stevie Ray Vaughan


Numbers in brackets indicate how many members (if more than one) have nominated this Nominee.

[wolfy35]

This is a difficult one because every name there more than deserves to be in.

My choice however would have to be "The big O" Roy Orbison only ever saw him live once and was blown away.

[melon]

Out of this list, I'd short list:

Johnny Cash
Ray Charles
Sammy Davis Jnr
George Harrison
Jimi Hendrix
Buddy Holly
Janis Joplin
John Lennon
Freddy Mercury
Jim Morrison
Roy Orbison
Elvis Presley
Bon Scott

All of these names were one of the biggest names in the business at their peaks, and their names still revered as the best.

I don't know how many you're putting through mouse but imo it would be a crime to miss any of the names I mentioned above.

Sent from my HTC Incredible S using Forum Runner

[Julie in the rv mirror]

I can't say that anyone on the list shouldn't be there. I propose that this category be a special one- sort of a "Hall of Remembrance" and everybody gets in. :cool:

[melon]

I can't say that anyone on the list shouldn't be there. I propose that this category be a special one- sort of a "Hall of Remembrance" and everybody gets in. :cool:

Agreed

Sent from my HTC Incredible S using Forum Runner

[BostonAngel]

I can't say that anyone on the list shouldn't be there. I propose that this category be a special one- sort of a "Hall of Remembrance" and everybody gets in. :cool:

I agree! They all deserve to be in there.

[The Flying Mouse]

:twisted: Because that's (http://www.mlukfc.com/forums/showpost.php?p=584799&postcount=2) why!

[The Flying Mouse]

I can't say that anyone on the list shouldn't be there. I propose that this category be a special one- sort of a "Hall of Remembrance" and everybody gets in. :cool:

Agreed

Sent from my HTC Incredible S using Forum Runner

I agree! They all deserve to be in there.

:twisted: I'd been playing with the idea of this for a few days.

On the one hand..................

An award for being dead feels a bit, odd. Death isn't a contest so should there be a contest to get in?

I wouldn't like to be the one to tell someone their favourite artist doesn't get into our hall of rememberance for something as calculating as a "vote".
Pardon the pun, but I think there should be "heaven for everyone". 8)

We've got the roon.

It's mlukfc, not a Russian gaulag (despite what some of our members might say :lawl: ).
We can afford to be flexable.

On the other...............

If we admit everyone now, we would basically be waiting round to lose someone else before we could make another induction.

Although I said above there should be heaven for everyone, i'd like to see some kind of standard maintained.
If someone is an admirer of an artist/writer/producer/musician/etc, I don't see a problem inducting them to a hall of rememberance, but I get the niggly feeling that some folks would send me PM's full of people who they've named just because they are dead. No matter if they have any personal interest in that person, and no matter how obscure they may be.
I kind of get the image of Wario looking through wikipedia to find out who's dead just to furnish me with a nice long list to pack the place out a bit :panic: .

How to find a compromise?

As a footnote, I think this is the one category where people from the Meat Loaf world deserve their own place (i'm thinging of Wells Kelly and Steve Popovich here).

[wolfy35]

:

How to find a compromise?

.

Maybe consider if people are as popular & revered still today after their death as they were during life. Strangely enough all the people in the nominations list fit that bill.

Without trying to sound harsh simply being dead and once popular is not enough.

[The Flying Mouse]

:twisted: Mulling this over for a few days, for this, our first year, I wouldn't mind seeing all of the above inducted.
Along with Wells Kelly and Steve Popovich.

There are still plenty of people we can induct in the future.

Anyone got any objection to that?

[melon]

No objection here

Sent from my HTC Incredible S using Forum Runner

[stretch37]

+1 for DIO.

:cool:

[BostonAngel]

:twisted: Mulling this over for a few days, for this, our first year, I wouldn't mind seeing all of the above inducted.
Along with Wells Kelly and Steve Popovich.

There are still plenty of people we can induct in the future.

Anyone got any objection to that?

No objection from me!

[chairboys]

+1 for DIO.

:cool:

He is hungry for heaven.