Originally Posted by lyn (Post 560584)

Couldn't of agreed with you more there. :) You look at the live performance on Wetten Das and compare it to his live performance with the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra, and there is no lip synching. Meat isn't a performer like that at all.

Anyway Meat, your performance was nothing short of brilliant!

Originally Posted by BATOUTOFHEAVEN (Post 560587)

People seem to forget that HIAHB had no voice effects and so even his live performances of those songs will sound similar to the studio versions, don't mean he's lip syncing. :cool:

Originally Posted by lyn (Post 560580)

But did you really expect to get just boring or positive responses all the way through?

Originally Posted by stretch37 (Post 560586)

Don't pick on people just because of their opinion. It's not fair. These are discussion forums. key word discussion

Originally Posted by lyn (Post 560593)

That's exactly right mate, there was no voice affects on HIAHB at all. So they can't be said to be lip synched when done live either :cool:;):D

Originally Posted by loaferman61 (Post 560591)

Does not matter a bit to me if it was live or not. Meat was on a huge television show and hit a home run. No media controversy, no jokes at his expense. He showed all the nay-sayers they could go do those "three little words" and that is good enough for me. I pray the DVD sounds as good to watch in all its blu-ray, surround-sound goodness.

Originally Posted by Sarge (Post 560594)

Is it possible that you misunderstood my post?



I'll remind you of that post next time you complain about "whining" people who "pick" on Meat or favor Meat giving someone "a bit of a beating" for having the "wrong" opinion. :twisted:

Originally Posted by lyn (Post 560596)

Couldn't have said it better myself

Originally Posted by BATOUTOFHEAVEN (Post 560590)

CHSIB although there must be a more powerful word than perfection ;)

Originally Posted by duke knooby (Post 560598)

you can decide for yourselves, was it lip synched? was it live?

Originally Posted by BATOUTOFHEAVEN (Post 560590)

CHSIB although there must be a more powerful word than perfection ;)

Originally Posted by duke knooby (Post 560598)

i can almost feel a get back to the topic warning appearing... but as usual i wont help matters

please enjoy this performance meat did in 2003 to promote his then new single

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iHM5D1efQb8

you can decide for yourselves, was it lip synched? was it live? was it an excellent performance? would it help promote the album?

etc etc

or who cares... enjoy it or not :twisted:

Originally Posted by Sarge (Post 560600)

It's blocked in my country, so I suspect it's not live. ;)

Originally Posted by lyn (Post 560602)

I remember watching this clip, and it was a brilliant performance too :D Just love this song :) Thanks for sharing those, and regardless to what our opinions are on the lip synch thing, this clip you have shared here plus the live performance in Germany was simply brilliant, and our man Rock 'n' rolls well ;) :)

Originally Posted by ShelbyLee (Post 560603)

It's a magnificent performance! I'm so proud of Meat, Patti and the band.

Originally Posted by Sarge (Post 560606)

Blocked as well. :))

Originally Posted by Sarge (Post 560606)

Blocked as well. :))

Originally Posted by duke knooby (Post 560613)

try this one then, last one... i promise

Originally Posted by loaferman61

I pray the DVD sounds as good to watch in all its blu-ray, surround-sound goodness.

Originally Posted by Sarge (Post 560606)

Blocked as well. :))

Originally Posted by snider22 (Post 560626)

[...] why are so many videos blocked in your part of the world :??:

Originally Posted by Sarge

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/03/te...03youtube.html

Originally Posted by CarylB (Post 560546)

Well you might of course be much better informed and knowledgeable than some of us .. but I think being a fan means that you delight in a great performance, in hearing great vocals, in seeing Meat's delight. To me that's not naive .. simply positive, supportive, and one of those fans who actually ENJOYS hearing and watching the performer they follow. It was HIS voice, and some of us take our simple pleasures in that.



Why? They are entitled to make their own assumptions, just as you make yours (I suspect you weren't on the set or the soundboard, so you too are making an assumption based on what you consider to be the evidence). And if anyone wants to express what they think, and that happens (heaven forfend) to be at odds with your view, they are entitled to say what they think ..

Meat appeared on Wetten Das. He was great, and if some of us find that exciting so be it. I think it's terrific to be a fan who DOES get excited by seeing and hearing the performer I follow, simply enjoys it, doesn't need to examine it and dissect it, but can simply take pleasure in it and celebrate.

Caryl

Originally Posted by robgomm (Post 560551)

In my opinion for what it's worth the whole thing was live vocals. All Of Me was live vocals in my view because there was an ad lib that was different from the record.

I find it hard to believe that Meat would be able to lip sync the whole performance THAT perfectly, even the ad libs, if it was it was the best mime in history. Just like someone who said Lady Gaga lip synced at Children In Need when it was so obvious she didn't. The signs are there if you look hard enough that it's live, and I saw enough to convince me.

Originally Posted by Sarge (Post 560576)

I regret having started this thread. The same bullshit again and again. You post info on something fans might be interested in and sooner or later something someone has said is (ab)used as a pretext to start the same old "good fan / bad fan" argument.

Originally Posted by carole (Post 560629)

That's exactly right Caryl, I just enjoyed seeing Meat on TV again and thought he did brilliantly.

Carole