:up:

"Go back to the 80ies, Sarah Durkee and Paul Jacobs I want" - this is my choise. Why? Maybe because I was born in the 80-s. Maybe because I like Sarah Durkee and Paul Jacobs style. Or maybe because I love 80-s music :cool:. Maybe ... Anyway I don't want Steinman style, because without Jim, IMHO, it wouldn't be good.

I couldn't agree more Jenna :up:
I truly love all of Meat's albums .. but my favorites are HCTB and HIAHB :-)

I'm genuinely torn. I love Steinman songs and James Michael wrote amazing songs on CHSIB. I also love HIAH. As long as it's Meat, Patti, and the NLE, I know it will be amazing.

:twisted: I've a feeling that this is going to boil down to a "should the new album sound like Bat or HCTB" :bleh:

As long as they leave the rap out, i'm sure i'll be happy :up:

As i've said (many times, but we have many threads :shrug: ) it took a lot of the HCTB material time to grow on me (and some of it never has) but HIHB was a great return to form.

I'd be happy with Steinman, i'd be happy with HIHB without any rap, and anything in between.

I like the idea of another Jim Steinman penned and involved album w/ Meat Loaf on the vocals. I'm not sure who the musicians would be, but Patti, Paul, Kasim Sulton, Rory Dodd, John M, Avery and/or Alexander come to me instantly. Throw in Caswell or a Mrs. Loud and an unheard Steinman spoken track for bad measure ;) Brave and Crazy..

And if it isn't going to be Steinman related, I like the idea of P Jacobs and S Durkee returning for at least a song or few. And also Rick Brantley! This would have to include Bob Kulick of course ;) Put Kulick and Crook in the same studio and be interesting for sure. Especially if the album hits on the 'Song of Madness' 'Land Of The Pig' tone.. It would work.
Hang Cool had a lot of broad modern rock arrangements. Perhaps Brave and Crazy would be something with a harder edge. With Paul as producer, why not. Paul's work on Handbasket was a real good job. The material on that album is well done.

Like I see, Steinman wins.

It's obvius.
Jim Steinman puts a special atmosphere in his songs.
And if we think of the incredible musical work he did in the bat 2 with the inimitable vocals and great choirs, the quality and success in the production, ... is impossible not to be another Steinman album
I hope they both come together to revolutionize the world again!!


Bat Out Of Hell: Brave And crazy
All songs by Jim Steinman
Produced by Jim Steinman


Paul Crook: I'm sure he would be happy to discover the world Steinman.
regards

Fair enough ... but it looks like you're in a minority ... a Jim album is winning the poll hands down at the moment ;)

Eight options, and Jim is getting 75% of the vote - fairly emphatic if you ask me.

I for one agree with Jenna, and quite frankly the poll answers are phrased in such a way to skew the results so not so emphatic, especially with all those stupid ass options.

This poll only needed two options

Jim

No Jim

That is a poll that could provide a legit, emphatic answer

Sent from my iPad mini using Forum Runner

Or perhaps

Jim

No Jim

I don't mind as long as it's Meat

If Steinman had some songs that fitted with Meat's vision for the album I'd be OK with that. If not, fine. I love the path Meat is on now, that's what I'm looking forward to, and I doubt a poll of 50-100 people would push him off course anyway ;)

But it already does:

Jim (one option total) 75% of vote

No Jim (seven options total) 25% of vote

How is this not a legit, emphatic answer ?

Presumably Meat WILL be involved in the album at some stage ...

I believe that's what she was getting at, either way, she will just be happy to have something from Meat.

Sent from my HTC Incredible S using Forum Runner

this poll is overwhelmingly lop-sided. meat needs to take a serious note to this.

So people would blindly like to stumble down the path of an album full of Steinclunkers like Cry To Heaven than an album of dynamic tunes just because of the writer??

Great poll so glad it was multiple choice!

Amusing. However I believe I explained what I meant reasonably well:

I think Cry To Heaven at the end of Bat3 wasn't the idea of Jimmy. Bat3 was a strong and heavy material but the pruduction and Meat's voice was very far from good. I think people want Steinman songs but with perfect sound. And I think, Meat should see this topic because it shows what fans really want...

I think we know that nothing on the production of Bat3 was down to Jim, but that's hardly the point.

There will be some who want a complete Steinman album, written and produced by him, with perfect sound .. another BOOH. And this is 2012 and it won't happen.

This topic shows what people who post on the UK forum want. To extrapolate that to all that follow him would be speculation. BOOH caught a moment in its time. That level of sales is extraordinary and would never be repeated imo. His recent albums have sold well, and well enough that he is still able to bring out new albums .. and on disc. At every show I've been to in recent years, those in the audience love to hear the songs from that early era, but also show every evidence of enjoying his newer work.

I think Meat, who is working on his new album, will do what he wants to do artistically with Paul and a great band. Some will love it, some won't. But imo the thing that keeps him still working after so many years with undiminished energy, drive, creativity and enthusiasm is .. in his words, because he still has something to say, and to explore and to give. The only "should" in my view would be that he continues to do this as long as he feels that way.

I don't think this is something most people would agree with. To my ears the strength of Meat's voice on Bat 3 was excellent, and one of the best things about it. Most professional reviews I read for Bat 3 specifically noted how good he sounded, and even if their review of the overall package wasn't as good as the first two, I saw none that rated his voice as anything but excellent.

With respect, given recent events on this board I'd think most would avoid commenting such opinions as facts.

Sent from my iPhone using Forum Runner

You just answered your own question, 7 vs 1 it's skewed, like one of our bad political polls over here.

You only get a true answer with a 1 on 1 situation .

Until its 1 on 1 this poll really means nothing, it was a skewed attempt to get the answer that the pollster wanted, not the truth

Sent from my iPhone using Forum Runner

It doesn't worry me in the slightest that I may be in the minority with my opinion but this topic did ask what people's opinions were so I stated it. :D

I agree with the point Caryl made, this topic does not reflect the opinions of the whole fanbase and the UKF is only a small part of it. Even if Meat were to read it, it might not make any difference anyway. It's not all down to Meat and he has said in interviews in the past that he always holds the door open for Jim. Perhaps the reason why it hasn't happened is down to Jim and the way he works.

Really, with then already working on the recording of the album, that pretty much shows that there isn't any significant involvement from Steinman. The process is already moving to fast for his pace.

Sent from my iPhone using Forum Runner

Theoretically, he might have had these songs sitting around / been working on them on for the last five years in preparation for Brave and Crazy, for all we know :shrug: I'm with you in that I doubt he's involved, but its not impossible ;)

Also, I can't see people who are on the fringes of Meat Loaf fanship (in that they don't post here) differing in opinion from the poll. He isn't exactly famous for HCTB or HIAHB. I'd consider the people here to be his most dedicated fans, and if most of them want a Steinman album, is anyone who follows Meat's work even slightly less devoutly going to want otherwise? :shrug:

It was a cruel idea to mention theres a new album coming but to avoid giving any detail about it :lol:

Glaciers move too fast for Jim's pace. The album would not be released for at least 3 years if Jim were heavily involved. I think they barely got Bat2 out in time before the music world changed. I know the whole VH1 heavy rotation and specials would have been far less likely just a short time later when VH1 "evolved".