Quote:
Originally Posted by PanicLord
Agreed, but even when explaining why you believe something to be dogshit, there are (as you say) constructive, helpful, well meaning ways of saying it, and flaming.
|
Absolutely. So, why would it be wrong for a "fan" to offer an opinion that was less than stellar, provided it was presented in a respectful, constructive way?
Quote:
Originally Posted by PanicLord
To me, fans, by definition, would not explain in detail to the person they are a fan of, how much like dogshit what they have done is.
|
This seems to contradict your first paragraph. As a fan, isn't it better to explain
why you don't like something, rather than just say that you don't? (And by this, I don't mean pronounce it "dogshit") I would think the artist would appreciate honest (again, respectful, constructive) feedback. Otherwise, I think it's a bit like the Emperor's New Clothes. Personally, I'd want someone to tell me if my ass was hanging out.
(Please keep in mind I'm speaking in general terms and also playing a bit of the Devil's Advocate)