Quote:
Originally Posted by Julie in the rv mirror
Absolutely. So, why would it be wrong for a "fan" to offer an opinion that was less than stellar, provided it was presented in a respectful, constructive way?
This seems to contradict your first paragraph. As a fan, isn't it better to explain why you don't like something, rather than just say that you don't? (And by this, I don't mean pronounce it "dogshit") I would think the artist would appreciate honest (again, respectful, constructive) feedback. Otherwise, I think it's a bit like the Emperor's New Clothes. Personally, I'd want someone to tell me if my ass was hanging out. 
(Please keep in mind I'm speaking in general terms and also playing a bit of the Devil's Advocate) |
I think people here explain very clearly what they don't like and why...but the problem might be that recipient of this criticism isn't very happy to hear it...I think most of us already know it...
I don't know how artists feel...unfortunately, I don't have any special talents...so it's hard to say if they are hurt first and then realize that it's constructive criticism...or is it that because they are such an artistic and dramatic souls that they just get hurt by any kind of criticism, even if it comes from their peers...