okay so rakes of folk will be like "oh you cant split them they are both awesome"
thats fine, and we all know how good they BOTH are.. but i will attempt to answer your question.
Personally its Paul Crook for me EVERY time. this is due to him being Metal Loaf and my love of metal. he also in my opinion has the best guitars out of the two of them and the best guitar tone.
this all showed for me on Bat Outta Hell, a solo which he played BEAUTIFULLY at Glasgow 16th December 2010 at the SECC. all his other solos where gorgeous too.
though i am sure many of my fellow glasgow gig attendees would agree the Duel Solo was incredible and the best solo of the night.
and for those who may not have noticed, it was the "freebird" solo they fit into the track and they nailed it NOTE for NOTE at the same time.(i was right at the barrier watching in awe.
so i have answered your question but then sidetracked back to exactly how i said people would reply by making sure everyone remembers how good they both are :P
|