[robgomm]

Originally Posted by CarylB

But would it have the same appeal to radio now? The business has moved on a lot in the last 18 years. It was an amazing song and a triumph, and once it was being played it caught on and spread across the airwaves, but back then where were still radio presenters who'd buck the system of playlists proscribed by the suits ..

I love All Of Me, and I could see it having a broad appeal, the music sticking in people's minds, and the "chorus" lyrics catching on, and not just to Meat Loaf fans. And a poll consisting of 65 votes from Meat Loaf fans on one fan site (64 if you take away the one for "a mystery song") isn't exactly a robust set of statistics imo as a basis of deciding a single release to the widest market, particularly give the framing of it .. eg (again) after two of the titles. I'd hope Sony have a more sound approach to testing the potential market.

I don't hope anybody is horribly wrong .. just that Sony are informed and right in all they do

Caryl