[mickp]

I take this for what it is, a great insight into how the album was put together. It can't be compared with the final product. Meat's version is one of my favourite tracks of all time, but who knows how a Rory version would have sounded after several weeks, multiple takes and remixing? As a live take with the band (with a few BGV overdubs only) to provide something for Meat to listen to and take a guide from I still think it rocks. Would have been fascinating if Jim and Jimmy had seen it to a conclusion with Meat although the end result may have been quite similar to where it ended up

I also think some of the vocals on BFG are outstanding, especially LITD and Surfs Up - I love the raw passion in frying pan and BFG also. To be honest, I often flip between which versions of songs I prefer and there are few that I don't like. DR on balance possibly just shades it as my second favourite collection of JS songs after BOOH (and also my 2nd favourite Meat album). I find all the songs accessible and standing the test of time well. I also prefer the rock based feel.