Rock star survey - Page 2

RSG · 04 Jan 2004, 04:44

I'm still discovering new bands, well new to me, so gimme some credit, lol. Older rock is much better than newer rock, although there are some great artists out there, who are new. I rated them best at the top. The More Stars the better.

Meat Loaf ******
Queen ******
Ozzy Osbourne *****
Aerosmith *****
Billy Joel *****
Nirvana ****
Pink Floyd *****
Elvis Presley ****
Metallica *****

plukie · 04 Jan 2004, 10:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by AndyNI

No Axl Rose? That's crazy. Crazy!

I think Axl Rose in the 80's or early 90's would have been there, but lately, he has lost it slightly. Before you jump down my throat, I have been a Guns n Roses fan for ages, and I really rate Axl Rose both as a singer and a looker but his latest songs from Chinese Democracy onwards have seemed as though he has lost the ability to scream! All voices change with age, and as you know Axl had problems with his voice after years of screaming on stage, that is not to say that he is now over and done with, he is still good but in a different way, a way that is not (in my opinion) so good as he used to be.

plukie · 04 Jan 2004, 10:54

My Top Ten Bands Are:-

1. Guns n Roses
2. Metallica
3. Meat Loaf
4. Black Sabbath
5. Queen

Can't really think of any more bands plenty of singers but these are my real favourite bands.

Bohemian · 04 Jan 2004, 12:04

My top ten artists or bands... in no order would be:

(Well I am not one to classify music - it's dodgy at the best of times. I just hope that this list is of what the majority of you guys would consider "Rock").

-> The Beatles
-> George Harrison
-> Alice Cooper
-> John Lennon
-> Meat Loaf
-> Talking Heads
-> Annie Lennox
-> Todd Rundgren
-> ELO / Jeff Lynne
-> Elton John

Bohemian

AndyNI · 04 Jan 2004, 15:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by plukie

Quote:

Originally Posted by AndyNI

No Axl Rose? That's crazy. Crazy!

I think Axl Rose in the 80's or early 90's would have been there, but lately, he has lost it slightly. Before you jump down my throat, I have been a Guns n Roses fan for ages, and I really rate Axl Rose both as a singer and a looker but his latest songs from Chinese Democracy onwards have seemed as though he has lost the ability to scream! All voices change with age, and as you know Axl had problems with his voice after years of screaming on stage, that is not to say that he is now over and done with, he is still good but in a different way, a way that is not (in my opinion) so good as he used to be.

anarchy agrees.

But Madagascar is one cool song.

Rob The Badger · 04 Jan 2004, 18:24

I love Top Ten's!

10. Meat Loaf
9. David Bowie
8. Radiohead
7. Manic Street Preachers
6. The Flaming Lips
5. The Darnkess
4. Talking Heads
3. The Beach Boys
2. The Beatles
1. The Smiths

*This list will probably be different tommorow except the top two spots, which remain firmly in the hold of The Beatles and The Smiths*

plymboy · 04 Jan 2004, 20:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChrissybabezNI

Pete Doherty (Libertines) ---- Maybe im stupid but I have never heard of him, or the group name

join the club

plymboy · 04 Jan 2004, 20:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by AndyNI

No Axl Rose? That's crazy. Crazy!

theyre f**king crazy!!!!

plymboy · 04 Jan 2004, 20:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by plukie

Quote:

Originally Posted by AndyNI

No Axl Rose? That's crazy. Crazy!

I think Axl Rose in the 80's or early 90's would have been there, but lately, he has lost it slightly. Before you jump down my throat, I have been a Guns n Roses fan for ages, and I really rate Axl Rose both as a singer and a looker but his latest songs from Chinese Democracy onwards have seemed as though he has lost the ability to scream! All voices change with age, and as you know Axl had problems with his voice after years of screaming on stage, that is not to say that he is now over and done with, he is still good but in a different way, a way that is not (in my opinion) so good as he used to be.

bless his cheek lmplanted face

Rob The Badger · 04 Jan 2004, 22:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by plymboy

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChrissybabezNI

Pete Doherty (Libertines) ---- Maybe im stupid but I have never heard of him, or the group name

join the club

You should check them out. They're very good.

shadow1000001 · 05 Jan 2004, 02:39

My top 10 would be:

1. Meat Loaf
2. AC/DC
3. Ozzy
4. Bon Jovi
5. Queen ( the early stuff)
6. Aerosmith
7. Def Leppard
8. Alice Cooper
9. Gun's N' Roses
10. Poison

little_dancer · 05 Jan 2004, 19:00

1- Meat Loaf
2- Frank Black (The Pixies)
3- Ozzy
4- Kurt Cobain (Nirvana)
5- David Bowie
6- Elvis
7- Jimmy Hendrix
8- Gwen Steffani
9- The Darkness
10- The Ramones (any of 'em)

Draven · 05 Jan 2004, 19:16

Hmmmm top 10

1. Guns N roses
2. Meat
3. Kiss
4. Iron Maiden
5. Van Halen
6. Metallica
7. AC/DC
8. The Darkness
9. Alice cooper (early stuff though, not any of that poison lark...altho that was great for his comeback)
10. Nirvana

Again though it depends on how you decide what rock n roll is, i mean many of the above bands can be put in to categories such as metal, grunge etc... so does that just make them alternative and not rock n roll?

Bon Jovi are good, id say they are kinda softrock or pop rock, im not sure. Like i said there are 2 many labels attached to music these days its terrible, i mean busted are labled as punk pop or pop punk whichever, when they are clearly just a boy band, and punk pop are bands like blink 182, bowling for soup, etc

Rob The Badger · 05 Jan 2004, 22:47

I can't believe I missed Nirvana!
Anyway, the good name of punk (The Clash, Stiff Little Fingers, The Ramones etc) is being dragged through the dirt recently, Busted and Good Charlotte punk? Pah, gimme a break.

Chris · 05 Jan 2004, 23:55

In NO PATICULAR ORDER!!!!

Meat
Alice Cooper
Bruce Springsteen
The Sex Pistols
Genesis
Heart
Queen
Bon Jovi (the earlier stuff)
Robert palmer
The Darkness

little_dancer · 06 Jan 2004, 00:32

Badger !!! How are you my furry little friend?!

I know what you mean re: 'the good name of punk'...I have to be honest, I clasify things in only 1 of three categories now: Pop, Rock, or Hip Hop...the slippery and ever-changing lines of Disco, indie, punk, heavy metal, techno, hip hop, rap, country, alternative -to name but a few!-(ha!) etc. are just far too dificult (and IMO pretentious) to navigate!!!

I know what punk feels like, and that's the only way to classify it... (and it sure don't feel like Good Charlotte or Blink 182

)

04 Jan 2004, 04:44	#26
RSG Mega Loafer Join Date: 27.07.2003 Location: Canada Posts: 3,296	I'm still discovering new bands, well new to me, so gimme some credit, lol. Older rock is much better than newer rock, although there are some great artists out there, who are new. I rated them best at the top. The More Stars the better. Meat Loaf **** Queen ** Ozzy Osbourne * Aerosmith * Billy Joel * Nirvana Pink Floyd * Elvis Presley Metallica ***

04 Jan 2004, 10:54	#28
plukie Senior Loafer Join Date: 18.07.2003 Location: Plymouth, Devon Posts: 199	My Top Ten Bands Are:- 1. Guns n Roses 2. Metallica 3. Meat Loaf 4. Black Sabbath 5. Queen Can't really think of any more bands plenty of singers but these are my real favourite bands.

04 Jan 2004, 12:04	#29
Bohemian Super Loafer Join Date: 14.11.2002 Location: Belgium Posts: 496	My top ten artists or bands... in no order would be: (Well I am not one to classify music - it's dodgy at the best of times. I just hope that this list is of what the majority of you guys would consider "Rock"). -> The Beatles -> George Harrison -> Alice Cooper -> John Lennon -> Meat Loaf -> Talking Heads -> Annie Lennox -> Todd Rundgren -> ELO / Jeff Lynne -> Elton John Bohemian

04 Jan 2004, 18:24	#31
Rob The Badger Too sexy for this post Join Date: 14.04.2002 Location: Manchester, UK Posts: 2,895	I love Top Ten's! 10. Meat Loaf 9. David Bowie 8. Radiohead 7. Manic Street Preachers 6. The Flaming Lips 5. The Darnkess 4. Talking Heads 3. The Beach Boys 2. The Beatles 1. The Smiths This list will probably be different tommorow except the top two spots, which remain firmly in the hold of The Beatles and The Smiths

05 Jan 2004, 02:39	#36
shadow1000001 Mega Loafer Join Date: 10.07.2003 Location: Red Deer, Alberta, Canada Posts: 2,580	My top 10 would be: 1. Meat Loaf 2. AC/DC 3. Ozzy 4. Bon Jovi 5. Queen ( the early stuff) 6. Aerosmith 7. Def Leppard 8. Alice Cooper 9. Gun's N' Roses 10. Poison

05 Jan 2004, 19:00	#37
little_dancer Super Loafer Join Date: 23.06.2003 Location: Toronto, Canada Posts: 363	1- Meat Loaf 2- Frank Black (The Pixies) 3- Ozzy 4- Kurt Cobain (Nirvana) 5- David Bowie 6- Elvis 7- Jimmy Hendrix 8- Gwen Steffani 9- The Darkness 10- The Ramones (any of 'em)

05 Jan 2004, 19:16	#38
Draven Junior Loafer Join Date: 13.04.2003 Posts: 38	Hmmmm top 10 1. Guns N roses 2. Meat 3. Kiss 4. Iron Maiden 5. Van Halen 6. Metallica 7. AC/DC 8. The Darkness 9. Alice cooper (early stuff though, not any of that poison lark...altho that was great for his comeback) 10. Nirvana Again though it depends on how you decide what rock n roll is, i mean many of the above bands can be put in to categories such as metal, grunge etc... so does that just make them alternative and not rock n roll? Bon Jovi are good, id say they are kinda softrock or pop rock, im not sure. Like i said there are 2 many labels attached to music these days its terrible, i mean busted are labled as punk pop or pop punk whichever, when they are clearly just a boy band, and punk pop are bands like blink 182, bowling for soup, etc

05 Jan 2004, 22:47	#39
Rob The Badger Too sexy for this post Join Date: 14.04.2002 Location: Manchester, UK Posts: 2,895	I can't believe I missed Nirvana! Anyway, the good name of punk (The Clash, Stiff Little Fingers, The Ramones etc) is being dragged through the dirt recently, Busted and Good Charlotte punk? Pah, gimme a break.

05 Jan 2004, 23:55	#40
Chris Mega Loafer Join Date: 14.04.2002 Location: Somewhere in the real world. Posts: 7,527	In NO PATICULAR ORDER!!!! Meat Alice Cooper Bruce Springsteen The Sex Pistols Genesis Heart Queen Bon Jovi (the earlier stuff) Robert palmer The Darkness

06 Jan 2004, 00:32	#41
little_dancer Super Loafer Join Date: 23.06.2003 Location: Toronto, Canada Posts: 363	Badger !!! How are you my furry little friend?! I know what you mean re: 'the good name of punk'...I have to be honest, I clasify things in only 1 of three categories now: Pop, Rock, or Hip Hop...the slippery and ever-changing lines of Disco, indie, punk, heavy metal, techno, hip hop, rap, country, alternative -to name but a few!-(ha!) etc. are just far too dificult (and IMO pretentious) to navigate!!! I know what punk feels like, and that's the only way to classify it... (and it sure don't feel like Good Charlotte or Blink 182 )