Meat Loaf joining American Idol ? - Page 2

Vickip · 30 Jul 2010, 05:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by suzieq

Just to add to the speculation

Another judge quit AI today. So 2 vacancies now.

Yes, I heard Ellen quit !

meat_loaf2008 · 30 Jul 2010, 05:33

who quit now

Vickip · 30 Jul 2010, 05:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by meat_loaf2008

who quit now

Ellen D

meat_loaf2008 · 30 Jul 2010, 07:46

-gasp- But I <3 Ellen.

24K · 30 Jul 2010, 14:16

Mm, i liked her, thought she was funny and odd in a nice way ! LOL...Will the show continue ? and if it does will i like it ? Dunno guess its a waiting game...

**allrevvedup** · 30 Jul 2010, 15:24

some other story going around about J-LO being a new judge

RoknRollJesus · 30 Jul 2010, 16:08

Saw on the news this morning that Steven Tyler is a possibility now too.

brooklynngrl · 30 Jul 2010, 16:08

AI usually begins in mid January, with broadcasting try-outs, but it's not in real time. Once they get their finalists, that's when they start broadcasting Live. So I doubt that would work out in Meat's schedule.

fred2010 · 30 Jul 2010, 19:05

i don't think it's gonna happen.....fox news had a pretty good write up and had 10 names you can vote for.....meat wasn't one of them....i voted 'other' and wrote meat's name in

glamourgirl · 30 Jul 2010, 19:30

Now it is being reported that Kara has been fired from AI:

http://www.tmz.com/2010/07/29/americ...n-tyler-fired/

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/show...ican-idol.html

Vickip · 30 Jul 2010, 20:15

Yes, the latest rumor is that Kara is out, Ellen will be replaced by Jennifer Lopez,
and they're going back to the 3 judge format, with Steven Tyler (from Aerosmith)
taking over for Simon / Kara

Now that's an interesting combination

Smithie · 30 Jul 2010, 21:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vickip

Yes, the latest rumor is that Kara is out, Ellen will be replaced by Jennifer Lopez,
and they're going back to the 3 judge format, with Steven Tyler (from Aerosmith)
taking over for Simon / Kara

Now that's an interesting combination

Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler would be interesting choices for the show. I think they need something big since they lost Simon and Ellen too. (And Paula in 2009.) I never really found Kara interesting on AI, and I prefer the 3-judge format.

24K · 30 Jul 2010, 21:10

This seems a little too odd, 3 judges gone, can't see it meself..i like Kara, will believe it when its all official.

Breeze · 30 Jul 2010, 21:20

If I had a shot at the AI seat,I'd cancel the tours . That is a very important seat . Look what it did for Simon Cowel? I think Meat would be perfect for that seat.

carole · 31 Jul 2010, 01:07

They were just talking about it here about Ellen leaving and they said that the guy who left because he didn't get on well with Simon was coming back, don't know his name, and they didn't mention Meat.

Carole

Pudding · 31 Jul 2010, 01:10

Lets be honest, Simon Cowell WAS American Idol and without him they can shove any celebrity monkeys on the judging panel and it won't be as good.

Breeze · 01 Aug 2010, 21:42

Meat has the talent, the longevity in the business, he's brave enough to say what he thinks and of course has that unpredictable artsy side too. He's sexy and sharp and AI should get on their knees and beg this amazing guy to take that spot.

he he Imagine getting feedback from Meat on your singing.

Sarahdk23 · 01 Aug 2010, 22:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by Breeze

he he Imagine getting feedback from Meat on your singing.

I would be scared to death! LOL

Vickip · 01 Aug 2010, 22:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sarahdk23

I would be scared to death! LOL

Wario · 01 Aug 2010, 23:15

what kinda makes me think I isnt meats thing is the show is about "hitting the right note" and stuff like that.

Meat's philosophy is you dont have to hit every note, just put on the best show you can possibly do.

Dunno if that mindset will work for a AI judge.

PS: Meats Philosophy is correct in every way.

Breeze · 02 Aug 2010, 00:28

Simon mixed it up and did not always judge things by the same yard stick. Meat would do the same thing. I am pretty sure he'd recognize talent if he saw it. Recall Patty's audition.

Wario · 02 Aug 2010, 00:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by Breeze

Recall Patty's audition.

no i dont. is it on film somewhere? Thatd be interesting

Breeze · 02 Aug 2010, 01:09

The story about her audition is something like she auditioned and thought she had blown it, kicked something( something along these lines) and then ended up being picked.
I'm sure in Meat's stories it must be somewhere. I read it somewhere.

Wario · 02 Aug 2010, 01:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by Breeze

The story about her audition is something like she auditioned and thought she had blown it, kicked something( something along these lines) and then ended up being picked.
I'm sure in Meat's stories it must be somewhere. I read it somewhere.

ill start a thread for this, its a bit off the topic aha

Pudding · 02 Aug 2010, 01:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by Breeze

he's brave enough to say what he thinks

He wasn't brave enough to say what he thought at the time when Bat3 was being made

I think Meat tries to please others first and holds back on his true feelings until a later date, where Cowell pleases himself first and says what he thinks on the spot regardless of who is in front of him.

30 Jul 2010, 05:33	#27
meat_loaf2008 Banned Join Date: 10.04.2007 Posts: 462	who quit now

30 Jul 2010, 07:46	#29
meat_loaf2008 Banned Join Date: 10.04.2007 Posts: 462	-gasp- But I <3 Ellen.

30 Jul 2010, 14:16	#30
24K Mega Loafer Join Date: 20.10.2003 Location: WAY UP NORTH Posts: 1,923	Mm, i liked her, thought she was funny and odd in a nice way ! LOL...Will the show continue ? and if it does will i like it ? Dunno guess its a waiting game...

30 Jul 2010, 15:24	#31
allrevvedup "Most things that i worry about, never happen anyway" Join Date: 29.11.2003 Location: Liverpool Posts: 5,351	some other story going around about J-LO being a new judge

30 Jul 2010, 16:08	#32
RoknRollJesus Livin' La Vida Loafa! Join Date: 03.10.2003 Location: North Carolina Posts: 1,529	Saw on the news this morning that Steven Tyler is a possibility now too.

30 Jul 2010, 16:08	#33
brooklynngrl Rookie Join Date: 10.04.2010 Posts: 2	AI usually begins in mid January, with broadcasting try-outs, but it's not in real time. Once they get their finalists, that's when they start broadcasting Live. So I doubt that would work out in Meat's schedule.

30 Jul 2010, 19:05	#34
fred2010 Senior Loafer Join Date: 31.03.2010 Posts: 143	i don't think it's gonna happen.....fox news had a pretty good write up and had 10 names you can vote for.....meat wasn't one of them....i voted 'other' and wrote meat's name in

30 Jul 2010, 19:30	#35
glamourgirl Super Loafer Join Date: 15.09.2009 Posts: 642	Now it is being reported that Kara has been fired from AI: http://www.tmz.com/2010/07/29/americ...n-tyler-fired/ http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/show...ican-idol.html

30 Jul 2010, 20:15	#36
Vickip Mega Loafer Join Date: 07.02.2003 Location: Posts: 8,101	Yes, the latest rumor is that Kara is out, Ellen will be replaced by Jennifer Lopez, and they're going back to the 3 judge format, with Steven Tyler (from Aerosmith) taking over for Simon / Kara Now that's an interesting combination

30 Jul 2010, 21:10	#38
24K Mega Loafer Join Date: 20.10.2003 Location: WAY UP NORTH Posts: 1,923	This seems a little too odd, 3 judges gone, can't see it meself..i like Kara, will believe it when its all official.

30 Jul 2010, 21:20	#39
Breeze Miss Inclined Join Date: 24.07.2010 Location: Posts: 448	If I had a shot at the AI seat,I'd cancel the tours . That is a very important seat . Look what it did for Simon Cowel? I think Meat would be perfect for that seat.

31 Jul 2010, 01:07	#40
carole Mega Loafer Join Date: 20.10.2007 Location: Gold Coast Posts: 2,286	They were just talking about it here about Ellen leaving and they said that the guy who left because he didn't get on well with Simon was coming back, don't know his name, and they didn't mention Meat. Carole

31 Jul 2010, 01:10	#41
Pudding I'm A Prize Fight Lover... Join Date: 22.10.2003 Location: New Zealand Posts: 5,532	Lets be honest, Simon Cowell WAS American Idol and without him they can shove any celebrity monkeys on the judging panel and it won't be as good.

01 Aug 2010, 21:42	#42
Breeze Miss Inclined Join Date: 24.07.2010 Location: Posts: 448	Meat has the talent, the longevity in the business, he's brave enough to say what he thinks and of course has that unpredictable artsy side too. He's sexy and sharp and AI should get on their knees and beg this amazing guy to take that spot. he he Imagine getting feedback from Meat on your singing.

01 Aug 2010, 23:15	#45
Wario Monstro helps me spell things... Join Date: 05.01.2007 Location: Masculine, Pennsylvania Posts: 9,105	what kinda makes me think I isnt meats thing is the show is about "hitting the right note" and stuff like that. Meat's philosophy is you dont have to hit every note, just put on the best show you can possibly do. Dunno if that mindset will work for a AI judge. PS: Meats Philosophy is correct in every way.

02 Aug 2010, 00:28	#46
Breeze Miss Inclined Join Date: 24.07.2010 Location: Posts: 448	Simon mixed it up and did not always judge things by the same yard stick. Meat would do the same thing. I am pretty sure he'd recognize talent if he saw it. Recall Patty's audition.

02 Aug 2010, 01:09	#48
Breeze Miss Inclined Join Date: 24.07.2010 Location: Posts: 448	The story about her audition is something like she auditioned and thought she had blown it, kicked something( something along these lines) and then ended up being picked. I'm sure in Meat's stories it must be somewhere. I read it somewhere.