Michelle compared to Meatloaf (merged)

izzy · 13 Dec 2003, 16:15

Hi on the Scottish edition of the newspaper this article was front page news but in England it is within the paper.

http://www.thesun.co.uk/article/0,,2-2003572957,00.html

Hope the link works.

DebGreaves · 13 Dec 2003, 16:29

The link works izzy, just read the article. Hope Micheele gets through to the final, we need someone who is different in the music industry

Debs

Sapphire Lady · 13 Dec 2003, 16:46

Did anyone notice 2 weeks ago on Pop Idol they showed childhood photos of each of the contestants to the music of the first single they bought? Mark's was Anything for Love.

Michelle has a brilliant voice and as a fellow Scot I'm certainly going to be voting for her tonight.

Rob The Badger · 13 Dec 2003, 17:04

That Cowell's got his head screwed on, no doubt about it.

dottie · 13 Dec 2003, 18:34

The Sun Saturday December 13th 2003

QUOTE: Pop Idol judge Simon Cowell last night backed Michelle McManus to win - and compared her to rocker Meat Loaf.

TV's Mr Nasty said the 15st Glasgow lass could easily be a star like the heavyweight Bat Out of Hell star.

And he added, "When you see Meat Loaf in a video, you don't think he's the best looking guy on earth - you just think he's got a great voice and a great personality.

dottie · 13 Dec 2003, 18:44

Sorry about this R. Double Posted this in General Messages with type written article

sherrie87 · 13 Dec 2003, 18:54

Oh my, theres all this fuss about Michelle being a "big girl"- and I just put her weight into a converter to see what it works out to in American pounds only to discover that she only weighs about 3 pounds more than me! Yikes! I guess there's no "American Idol" in my future. Oh well...as I said to someone who asked about my weight- I'm no Meat Loaf, but I'm about 1 and 3/4 Patti Russo's!

Sherrie

Jayd · 13 Dec 2003, 18:57

Yep, I read this too. Small picture of Meat there also.

Shellyb01 · 13 Dec 2003, 21:39

Anyway, at the end of the day, size doesn't matter - I'm not the slimmest of women, but I'm not the biggest, I could probably do with losing some weight, and sometimes (in fact most times) I look at myself and really really hate what I see

, but then I remember that I'm loved, and it's not because of what I wear, or what I look like, it because I'm me, and we're all just amazing beings, and we were put on this earth by whoever, or whatever you believe in for a reason ....... so it shouldn't matter what size, age, colour or whatever you are ...... we're all individuals and to me we're all special ..... (on this site anyway!!! :) ) There's too much sterotyping that goes on in this world, if people stopped, took a step back and actually took time to get to know that person they'd find someone truly wonderful .... :)

and that's all I have to say!

Love'n'stuff

Shelly
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

DIZZY DRUMMER · 13 Dec 2003, 22:45

Shellyb01 - I agree fully. I am also larger than life. But at the end of the day I am happy. I have a lovely husband & daughter.

I have a job I enjoy & collegues I have fun with.
I can't sing to save my life, but my sense of humour makes up for it.

We are all unique & special. I love the fact that everyone is appreciated on this site - keep up the good work.

Vote Michelle 2nite

Keep Rockin everyone :P

meatfan · 14 Dec 2003, 01:07

how I endorse some of these comments!

I am 12 stone - and my lovely hubby is - (wait for it)

18 stone 9lb and fitter than many men who weigh far less!

Heather.

shadow1000001 · 14 Dec 2003, 01:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by meatfan

how I endorse some of these comments!

I am 12 stone - and my lovely hubby is - (wait for it)

18 stone 9lb and fitter than many men who weigh far less!

Heather.

I'm sorry but I have to ask, How many pounds is 12 stone

Maria

ChrissybabezNI · 14 Dec 2003, 02:16

12 stone is 132 pounds i think theres 11 pounds in a stone.

angel eyes · 14 Dec 2003, 02:26

Sorry to say but there are 14 pounds in a stone.

In this life people should treat people for what they are like and not pre judge on looks alone.

Love

Angelxxx

shadow1000001 · 14 Dec 2003, 03:40

Thanks Chrissy and Angel Eyes

Bigmomma · 14 Dec 2003, 12:34

the name is big momma, need i say more

and just for my ideas, it is the personality what counts not the stuff
on the outside, fat or thin, look at simon cowell, he is nice and thin
but has he got a nice personality ?
my granny allways said a rosy apple can be rotten inside,.....

DebGreaves · 14 Dec 2003, 12:46

You are so right there Bigmomma, its whats on the inside that counts. I hope that Michelle wins next week, she deserves to. Im fed up of hearing other people bitching about her because of her weight. After all im not exactly the slimmest woman, lol, but I know people love me, Im happy and have a great sense of humour.

Debs

White of High · 14 Dec 2003, 12:58

What is that blue thing in Meat's mouth???

Deb · 14 Dec 2003, 13:48

I'm in shock lol!!! standing at a Meat show in Sheffield last night and get a text message from my daughter!! SAM WENT OUT!!!! I can't believe it!! looks like Michelle will win now, unless Mark is a real dark horse, I really do like him though.

I have a theory on Sam going out though lol, doubt anyone else will see it (my family don't

) Sams from Barnsley, for those of you that don't know this is very near or in (not sure which) Sheffield. Now how many local people would of been at The Arena last night lol. ? It seems like the majority of the contestants fanbase is their local towns, so poor Sam must of had loads of his at the meat show lol. Including me!!!

Deb

Frying Pan · 14 Dec 2003, 18:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by White of High

What is that blue thing in Meat's mouth???

It must be chewing gum.

Cpl Mickey · 14 Dec 2003, 19:09

I think Michelle has a great voice. Does it really matter that she is not a stick, surely we should look past the exterior and see whats on the inside. Never judge a book by its cover. Good luck to her. I was a size 16-18 (uK size) when I got married, I am now about 22-24 (UK size) but my husband loves me as I am, he always says its whats on the inside that counts.

MLFAN17 · 14 Dec 2003, 20:23

I dont think Simon cares about Meats weight I mean look who won American Idol? This only seems to apply to women of his size or used to be size. I hope Michelle can do it for anyone of her size! I am in a wheelchair(alos not that skinny anymore unfortunately lol) and I know that even if I COULD sing I wouldnt make it in the business because of the wheelchair. I have been trying to think of others in rock music who have made itas far or longer then Meat has regardless of his size.

wideawakewesley · 17 Dec 2003, 01:01

Michelle compared to MeatLoaf, I nearly choked when I read that!

Sorry, but they can try and say she has all the personality in the world, but she doesn't. She's dull off stage, lifeless on stage and has a decent voice. If she writes her own songs, maybe she'll suceed, but if she doesn't, she hasn't got a cat in hells chance.

In fact all of this series of possible pop idols are nothing of the sort, give me Wil anyday!

Nellie1000 · 17 Dec 2003, 11:34

Big mistake Michelle! This morning Michelle is quoted as saying shes nothing like Meatloaf. She's attractive and Meat isn't. She's just lost my vote. She should understand that it was a complement to be compared to him. Simon Cowell was saying that you don't have to be stick thin to succeed in the music business not that she looks like him! I totally agree with the previous post.

christa · 17 Dec 2003, 13:46

I really cant see what all the fuss is about with this Michelle, Her voice aint bad but where is the personality? It s just not there.

I will be voting for Mark as he sings well and he has a nice cheeky sense of humour, well I would be voting if I wasn't out on the p--s with my mates!

As for Michelle saying she is better looking than Meat I would argue that one to the death! At 56 he is still as gorgeous as 20 years ago, will she be? Doubt it very much.

13 Dec 2003, 16:15	#1
izzy Junior Loafer Join Date: 19.11.2003 Posts: 25	Todays Sun Newspaper: Michelle compared to Meatloaf Hi on the Scottish edition of the newspaper this article was front page news but in England it is within the paper. http://www.thesun.co.uk/article/0,,2-2003572957,00.html Hope the link works.

13 Dec 2003, 18:34	#5
dottie queen post- whore extraordinaire Join Date: 29.01.2003 Location: Still Rockin' at "72" Posts: 13,181	Meat Loaf - Michelle McManus The Sun Saturday December 13th 2003 QUOTE: Pop Idol judge Simon Cowell last night backed Michelle McManus to win - and compared her to rocker Meat Loaf. TV's Mr Nasty said the 15st Glasgow lass could easily be a star like the heavyweight Bat Out of Hell star. And he added, "When you see Meat Loaf in a video, you don't think he's the best looking guy on earth - you just think he's got a great voice and a great personality.

13 Dec 2003, 16:29	#2
DebGreaves Senior Loafer Join Date: 24.11.2003 Location: South Yorkshire Posts: 167	The link works izzy, just read the article. Hope Micheele gets through to the final, we need someone who is different in the music industry Debs

13 Dec 2003, 16:46	#3
Sapphire Lady Mega Loafer Join Date: 21.04.2003 Location: Scotland Posts: 1,213	Did anyone notice 2 weeks ago on Pop Idol they showed childhood photos of each of the contestants to the music of the first single they bought? Mark's was Anything for Love. Michelle has a brilliant voice and as a fellow Scot I'm certainly going to be voting for her tonight.

13 Dec 2003, 17:04	#4
Rob The Badger Too sexy for this post Join Date: 14.04.2002 Location: Manchester, UK Posts: 2,895	That Cowell's got his head screwed on, no doubt about it.

13 Dec 2003, 18:44	#6
dottie queen post- whore extraordinaire Join Date: 29.01.2003 Location: Still Rockin' at "72" Posts: 13,181	Sorry about this R. Double Posted this in General Messages with type written article

13 Dec 2003, 18:54	#7
sherrie87 Mega Loafer Join Date: 20.02.2003 Location: Largo, FL Posts: 1,262	Oh my, theres all this fuss about Michelle being a "big girl"- and I just put her weight into a converter to see what it works out to in American pounds only to discover that she only weighs about 3 pounds more than me! Yikes! I guess there's no "American Idol" in my future. Oh well...as I said to someone who asked about my weight- I'm no Meat Loaf, but I'm about 1 and 3/4 Patti Russo's! Sherrie

13 Dec 2003, 18:57	#8
Jayd If I could bust into hell....... I would Join Date: 13.06.2003 Location: Montclair, New Jersey Posts: 1,312	Yep, I read this too. Small picture of Meat there also.

13 Dec 2003, 21:39	#9
Shellyb01 Loafer Join Date: 24.10.2003 Location: Merseyside Posts: 82	Anyway, at the end of the day, size doesn't matter - I'm not the slimmest of women, but I'm not the biggest, I could probably do with losing some weight, and sometimes (in fact most times) I look at myself and really really hate what I see , but then I remember that I'm loved, and it's not because of what I wear, or what I look like, it because I'm me, and we're all just amazing beings, and we were put on this earth by whoever, or whatever you believe in for a reason ....... so it shouldn't matter what size, age, colour or whatever you are ...... we're all individuals and to me we're all special ..... (on this site anyway!!! :) ) There's too much sterotyping that goes on in this world, if people stopped, took a step back and actually took time to get to know that person they'd find someone truly wonderful .... :) and that's all I have to say! Love'n'stuff Shelly xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

13 Dec 2003, 22:45	#10
DIZZY DRUMMER Always Ready For A Bang Join Date: 30.11.2003 Location: Left In The Dark .......... AGAIN Posts: 6,389	Shellyb01 - I agree fully. I am also larger than life. But at the end of the day I am happy. I have a lovely husband & daughter. I have a job I enjoy & collegues I have fun with. I can't sing to save my life, but my sense of humour makes up for it. We are all unique & special. I love the fact that everyone is appreciated on this site - keep up the good work. Vote Michelle 2nite Keep Rockin everyone :P

14 Dec 2003, 01:07	#11
meatfan Super Loafer Join Date: 16.04.2003 Posts: 251	how I endorse some of these comments! I am 12 stone - and my lovely hubby is - (wait for it) 18 stone 9lb and fitter than many men who weigh far less! Heather.

14 Dec 2003, 02:16	#13
ChrissybabezNI Super Loafer Join Date: 18.11.2003 Location: Carrickfergus, Northern Ireland Posts: 352	12 stone is 132 pounds i think theres 11 pounds in a stone.

14 Dec 2003, 02:26	#14
angel eyes Senior Loafer Join Date: 18.11.2003 Location: North East Posts: 183	Sorry to say but there are 14 pounds in a stone. In this life people should treat people for what they are like and not pre judge on looks alone. Love Angelxxx

14 Dec 2003, 03:40	#15
shadow1000001 Mega Loafer Join Date: 10.07.2003 Location: Red Deer, Alberta, Canada Posts: 2,580	Thanks Chrissy and Angel Eyes

14 Dec 2003, 12:34	#16
Bigmomma Super Loafer Join Date: 07.07.2003 Location: Somewhere in time in my mind......... Posts: 655	the name is big momma, need i say more and just for my ideas, it is the personality what counts not the stuff on the outside, fat or thin, look at simon cowell, he is nice and thin but has he got a nice personality ? my granny allways said a rosy apple can be rotten inside,.....

14 Dec 2003, 12:46	#17
DebGreaves Senior Loafer Join Date: 24.11.2003 Location: South Yorkshire Posts: 167	You are so right there Bigmomma, its whats on the inside that counts. I hope that Michelle wins next week, she deserves to. Im fed up of hearing other people bitching about her because of her weight. After all im not exactly the slimmest woman, lol, but I know people love me, Im happy and have a great sense of humour. Debs

14 Dec 2003, 12:58	#18
White of High Nature's Siegfried Join Date: 27.05.2002 Location: Budapest, Hungary Posts: 2,930	What is that blue thing in Meat's mouth???

14 Dec 2003, 13:48	#19
Deb Mega Loafer Join Date: 26.04.2003 Location: Did I say that?... Posts: 4,162	I'm in shock lol!!! standing at a Meat show in Sheffield last night and get a text message from my daughter!! SAM WENT OUT!!!! I can't believe it!! looks like Michelle will win now, unless Mark is a real dark horse, I really do like him though. I have a theory on Sam going out though lol, doubt anyone else will see it (my family don't ) Sams from Barnsley, for those of you that don't know this is very near or in (not sure which) Sheffield. Now how many local people would of been at The Arena last night lol. ? It seems like the majority of the contestants fanbase is their local towns, so poor Sam must of had loads of his at the meat show lol. Including me!!! Deb

14 Dec 2003, 19:09	#21
Cpl Mickey Mega Loafer Join Date: 15.09.2003 Location: Maidstone. England Posts: 1,378	I think Michelle has a great voice. Does it really matter that she is not a stick, surely we should look past the exterior and see whats on the inside. Never judge a book by its cover. Good luck to her. I was a size 16-18 (uK size) when I got married, I am now about 22-24 (UK size) but my husband loves me as I am, he always says its whats on the inside that counts.

14 Dec 2003, 20:23	#22
MLFAN17 Senior Loafer Join Date: 06.02.2003 Location: Va Posts: 110	I dont think Simon cares about Meats weight I mean look who won American Idol? This only seems to apply to women of his size or used to be size. I hope Michelle can do it for anyone of her size! I am in a wheelchair(alos not that skinny anymore unfortunately lol) and I know that even if I COULD sing I wouldnt make it in the business because of the wheelchair. I have been trying to think of others in rock music who have made itas far or longer then Meat has regardless of his size.

17 Dec 2003, 01:01	#23
wideawakewesley Rookie Join Date: 02.12.2003 Posts: 3	Michelle compared to MeatLoaf, I nearly choked when I read that! Sorry, but they can try and say she has all the personality in the world, but she doesn't. She's dull off stage, lifeless on stage and has a decent voice. If she writes her own songs, maybe she'll suceed, but if she doesn't, she hasn't got a cat in hells chance. In fact all of this series of possible pop idols are nothing of the sort, give me Wil anyday!

17 Dec 2003, 11:34	#24
Nellie1000 Rookie Join Date: 19.11.2003 Posts: 7	Big mistake Michelle! This morning Michelle is quoted as saying shes nothing like Meatloaf. She's attractive and Meat isn't. She's just lost my vote. She should understand that it was a complement to be compared to him. Simon Cowell was saying that you don't have to be stick thin to succeed in the music business not that she looks like him! I totally agree with the previous post.

17 Dec 2003, 13:46	#25
christa Super Loafer Join Date: 23.05.2003 Location: Nottingham Posts: 663	I really cant see what all the fuss is about with this Michelle, Her voice aint bad but where is the personality? It s just not there. I will be voting for Mark as he sings well and he has a nice cheeky sense of humour, well I would be voting if I wasn't out on the p--s with my mates! As for Michelle saying she is better looking than Meat I would argue that one to the death! At 56 he is still as gorgeous as 20 years ago, will she be? Doubt it very much.