Live Bat Out Of Hell on new CD?

Puritan · 25 Apr 2003, 13:14

I was just reading the review of Meat's new album in "Classic Rock". The review goes on about how all writers seem to be trying to copy Steinman - but that it is never quite the same. But I guess the review could have been worse - the album is given three out of five stars which is the "good" category

The review at the end states that there is a live version (storytellers version I seem to have read somewhere) which it calls horrendous tacked on to the end of the album. My question is could someone who has bought the two CD set which is in the shops in the UK this week confirm whether that is on there. Certainly that track does not appear to have been on the copy that I bought from Germany - unless I am so dense that I can't find it which is more than likely!

Thanks

jcmoorehead · 25 Apr 2003, 13:18

Yes its on the album. Its track 12 on the first CD After Forever Young. It isnt actually shown on the back of the CD Cover.

Puritan · 25 Apr 2003, 13:25

Thanks for the information

I'll go and buy it then and give my German copy away

Another sale!

Bohemian · 25 Apr 2003, 14:06

I couldn't be happier that there's Bat live on the end. :) From all fan reviews I've heard it fits in beautifully (the sound gels nicely, I hear). I have the storytellers DVD but not the CD, and I used to put it in the player and just keep skipping between A Kiss Is A Terrible Thing To Waste and Bat Out Of Hell, for like, literally hours at a time. (When I was the only one home... my brothers wouldn't realy go for it).

It is such a great version. I love it. Plus, I think its cool when artists go back and re arrange their old stuff and re do it. I mean, Meat's been doing live versions of it the whole time and their all slightly different, but this is a basic studio recording, very different - played to perfection and finding Meat in absolute terrific voice.

Oh, I just can't wait...

Bohemian

Renegade Angel · 25 Apr 2003, 16:48

My Album has a little red sticker on the front that says 'Features Bat Out Of Hell as hidden track'
I read the review in Classic Rock today and I think what the reviewer is meaning is that Bat has been added to the album to make up for all the non-steinman songs so it will sell more copies, although im quite happy that it is on the album - it's a nice bonus.

Bohemien - I visited Brisbane last December - you are so lucky to live in such a nice place, I stayed in the Saville Abbey Hotel across from the transit centre - o u know it?
Also spent most evenings in 'Showgirls' (and most of my money)

Kai-H. · 25 Apr 2003, 21:01

Hi !

It's a special edition in Germany available from shop "MEDIA MARKT" > the double, features "Bat" and "You took the words" ( both from storytellers ) as bonus on disc 1 ....

Bye from Kai :P

Shane · 26 Apr 2003, 05:34

From which concert was the live Bat taken? I've got the German version which doesn't have it.

Does anyone know which issue of Rolling Stone had the review of CHSIB? I think it got 2.5 out of 5.

Vickip · 26 Apr 2003, 05:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shane

From which concert was the live Bat taken? I've got the German version which doesn't have it.

Does anyone know which issue of Rolling Stone had the review of CHSIB? I think it got 2.5 out of 5.

The Live Bat is from Storytellers

It's Track 12 on the UK version of the CD ... which I got from Amazon.com.uk today !

I'm not sure which issue that is ... but if I find out, I'll let you know :)
Vicki

Bohemian · 26 Apr 2003, 09:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by Renegade Angel

My Album has a little red sticker on the front that says 'Features Bat Out Of Hell as hidden track'
I read the review in Classic Rock today and I think what the reviewer is meaning is that Bat has been added to the album to make up for all the non-steinman songs so it will sell more copies, although im quite happy that it is on the album - it's a nice bonus.

Bohemien - I visited Brisbane last December - you are so lucky to live in such a nice place, I stayed in the Saville Abbey Hotel across from the transit centre - o u know it?
Also spent most evenings in 'Showgirls' (and most of my money)

Hello! Thank you so much for the nice words. I'm not a very well travlled fellow (been To Melbourne and around South East Queensland but never out of the country) but Brisbane realy is a nice place, I'd have to agree. :) Very nice location you had aswell. I so want to live in an inner city apartment when I actually make some real money and can afford it... That's the lifestyle for me.

Bohemian

Renegade Angel · 26 Apr 2003, 16:14

I have family in Perth so in 2001 I decided to vist them and then as I was in Oz visit Sydney and Brisbane and it really is a nice place and I loved it so much that I went back last December.
If I can afford it I might go again in 2004 cos I would love to go up to the barrier reef as I didn't get chance the last time.

Kai-H. · 26 Apr 2003, 16:37

Hi !

> the standart double-version of CHSIB in Germany got the order-nr. 076 117-2

> MEDIA MARKT-Edition ( Double feat. "Bat" & "Words" from Storytellers as bonus on disc one ) got the order-nr. 076 136-2

Hope this information will help ...

Bye from Kai

ChrisBelfast · 26 Apr 2003, 18:01

rolling stone gace it 3 out of 5 which is the equivalent to 'good'. they also called it his best in 25 years

25 Apr 2003, 13:14	#1
Puritan Super Loafer Join Date: 14.04.2002 Location: Banbury, United Kingdom Posts: 350	Live Bat Out Of Hell on new CD? I was just reading the review of Meat's new album in "Classic Rock". The review goes on about how all writers seem to be trying to copy Steinman - but that it is never quite the same. But I guess the review could have been worse - the album is given three out of five stars which is the "good" category The review at the end states that there is a live version (storytellers version I seem to have read somewhere) which it calls horrendous tacked on to the end of the album. My question is could someone who has bought the two CD set which is in the shops in the UK this week confirm whether that is on there. Certainly that track does not appear to have been on the copy that I bought from Germany - unless I am so dense that I can't find it which is more than likely! Thanks

26 Apr 2003, 05:34	#7
Shane Super Loafer Join Date: 30.04.2002 Location: Palmerston North, New Zealand (GMT+12) Posts: 608	which version? From which concert was the live Bat taken? I've got the German version which doesn't have it. Does anyone know which issue of Rolling Stone had the review of CHSIB? I think it got 2.5 out of 5.

26 Apr 2003, 16:37	#11
Kai-H. Loafer Join Date: 24.04.2003 Location: Stade - Germany Posts: 88	The differnt versions ... Hi ! > the standart double-version of CHSIB in Germany got the order-nr. 076 117-2 > MEDIA MARKT-Edition ( Double feat. "Bat" & "Words" from Storytellers as bonus on disc one ) got the order-nr. 076 136-2 Hope this information will help ... Bye from Kai

25 Apr 2003, 13:18	#2
jcmoorehead Super Loafer Join Date: 09.04.2003 Location: Edinburgh, formerly Teesside Posts: 671	Yes its on the album. Its track 12 on the first CD After Forever Young. It isnt actually shown on the back of the CD Cover.

25 Apr 2003, 13:25	#3
Puritan Super Loafer Join Date: 14.04.2002 Location: Banbury, United Kingdom Posts: 350	Thanks for the information I'll go and buy it then and give my German copy away Another sale!

25 Apr 2003, 14:06	#4
Bohemian Super Loafer Join Date: 14.11.2002 Location: Belgium Posts: 496	I couldn't be happier that there's Bat live on the end. :) From all fan reviews I've heard it fits in beautifully (the sound gels nicely, I hear). I have the storytellers DVD but not the CD, and I used to put it in the player and just keep skipping between A Kiss Is A Terrible Thing To Waste and Bat Out Of Hell, for like, literally hours at a time. (When I was the only one home... my brothers wouldn't realy go for it). It is such a great version. I love it. Plus, I think its cool when artists go back and re arrange their old stuff and re do it. I mean, Meat's been doing live versions of it the whole time and their all slightly different, but this is a basic studio recording, very different - played to perfection and finding Meat in absolute terrific voice. Oh, I just can't wait... Bohemian

25 Apr 2003, 16:48	#5
Renegade Angel Super Loafer Join Date: 20.04.2003 Location: UK Posts: 551	My Album has a little red sticker on the front that says 'Features Bat Out Of Hell as hidden track' I read the review in Classic Rock today and I think what the reviewer is meaning is that Bat has been added to the album to make up for all the non-steinman songs so it will sell more copies, although im quite happy that it is on the album - it's a nice bonus. Bohemien - I visited Brisbane last December - you are so lucky to live in such a nice place, I stayed in the Saville Abbey Hotel across from the transit centre - o u know it? Also spent most evenings in 'Showgirls' (and most of my money)

25 Apr 2003, 21:01	#6
Kai-H. Loafer Join Date: 24.04.2003 Location: Stade - Germany Posts: 88	Hi ! It's a special edition in Germany available from shop "MEDIA MARKT" > the double, features "Bat" and "You took the words" ( both from storytellers ) as bonus on disc 1 .... Bye from Kai :P

26 Apr 2003, 16:14	#10
Renegade Angel Super Loafer Join Date: 20.04.2003 Location: UK Posts: 551	I have family in Perth so in 2001 I decided to vist them and then as I was in Oz visit Sydney and Brisbane and it really is a nice place and I loved it so much that I went back last December. If I can afford it I might go again in 2004 cos I would love to go up to the barrier reef as I didn't get chance the last time.

26 Apr 2003, 18:01	#12
ChrisBelfast Mega Loafer Join Date: 18.02.2003 Location: Posts: 1,061	rolling stone gace it 3 out of 5 which is the equivalent to 'good'. they also called it his best in 25 years